Creating an Analysis

Start an analysis with the question you want to investigate. You can refine it with Hinsley before research begins, or start research immediately. Your analysis brings together the research, scenarios, drivers, and forecasts for that question.

Start Research

  1. On the Hinsley home page, enter your research question. Open Provide additional context for your question to add the decision, audience, scope, or time period you want the research to cover.
  2. Choose Validate my question to save a draft and review it with Hinsley, or Skip validation & start research to choose evidence sources for the question as written.
  3. If you chose validation, review the assessment and discuss changes in the chat. Select Apply or Apply all to accept suggested wording, or edit the Current draft form yourself.
  4. When ready, select Choose evidence sources below the draft form. You can continue even if the assessment identifies potential improvements.
  5. Review the preselected evidence sources, select at least one, then select Start research.

Evidence Sources

The analysis opens with a progress timeline. You can leave while research runs; Hinsley emails you when it finishes. Read the brief in Research Updates. The analysis chat becomes available when the initial research completes. See Research Briefs & Updates.

Refining a Draft

Use the chat to answer Hinsley's questions or ask for alternative wording. Suggestions leave your draft unchanged until you select Apply. Select Dismiss to decline a suggestion. You can also edit the question and optional context directly; edits save when you leave a field.

The question can contain up to 1,000 characters. Each optional context field can contain up to 5,000. Use Purpose or decision for the work the analysis supports, Audience for its readers, In scope and Out of scope to set boundaries, and Time period for the period to investigate. Historical, current, and future periods are supported.

For examples of how to frame your question, see Start With the Right Question.

After editing, select Re-assess current draft to review the new wording. This becomes available when the draft has changed since its last assessment. Research has not started yet, so the assessment evaluates the framing of your question rather than the available evidence.

Return to a Draft

Open Draft Analyses on the home page and select a draft to continue. Drafts are private to their creator, including from account admins. Once research starts, the draft leaves this list and the analysis appears under Your Analyses.

Select View Draft History to review earlier wording. If you edited the same draft in another tab, choose Save my wording or Use saved wording when prompted to resolve the difference.

An Out of date suggestion refers to wording you have since changed. Re-assessing marks pending suggestions from the earlier assessment as Superseded. Review suggestions against the current draft before applying them.

Starting research carries the question and context into the analysis. You can change them later in analysis settings. The draft becomes read-only and offers Open analysis.

Understand the Question Assessment

When the draft page opens, Hinsley reviews the question and posts a “Question assessment” in the chat. The assessment grades the draft against six criteria:

  • Serves a decision or reader - Answering the question would change what someone understands or does.
  • A right-sized question - The draft reads as a research question rather than a bare subject label, and is specific enough to give research a direction without narrowing to a single forecasting question.
  • Names who, where, and when - The actors, the place or domain, and the time period are identifiable. A past period counts.
  • Does not assume its own answer - The wording is neutral about the outcome.
  • The answer is not already settled - Informed people could reasonably reach different answers.
  • Evidence plausibly exists - The question is framed so that evidence for it could exist. This is a judgement on the framing only; no sources have been searched yet.

Each criterion receives one of three ratings:

  • Strong - The draft meets the criterion.
  • Worth sharpening - The draft could be improved on this point. A one-sentence comment explains why.
  • Not applicable to this draft - The criterion does not apply to this question.

The assessment has no overall score. Its header counts the criteria worth sharpening as potential improvements. A criterion marked “Needs your input” has a question for you, and its “Answer” button starts a chat reply to it. Other criteria worth sharpening offer “Suggest improvements”, which asks Hinsley to propose a change to the draft.

The assessment card also links to “What makes a strong analysis question?”, a guide that explains each criterion in more depth.

Account Limits

Every Hinsley plan sets two per-user limits that affect analysis creation:

  • Analyses created per month - How many new analyses each user can create in a rolling month. Drafts that have not started research do not count.
  • Active analyses per user - How many of a user’s analyses can be active at once. Deactivating an older analysis frees a slot.

If you hit either limit, the form on the home page is replaced with a notice explaining which limit was reached and how to upgrade your plan. The limits are checked again when you start research from the source-selection step. Your existing analyses remain fully accessible.

After Creation

Once the initial research completes, a typical next step is to explore the research brief, then either begin the analysis chat to develop your thinking, build a decomposition of the topic, or create scenarios and forecasting questions. You can also invite collaborators at any time.