Creating Multiple Decompositions

A single analysis can often be decomposed in more than one way. Different analysts may emphasize different drivers, or you may want to explore how changing the structure of a decomposition affects downstream indicators, forecasts, and scenarios. Hinsley lets you maintain multiple independent decompositions within the same analysis, each with its own drivers, indicators, and visualizations.

Why Use Multiple Decompositions?

Every analysis starts with one decomposition. Additional decompositions let you:

  • Explore alternative analytical frameworks - for example, decomposing a geopolitical question by regional actors in one decomposition and by thematic drivers (economic, military, diplomatic) in another
  • Preserve an established decomposition that a collaborator is working on while experimenting with a revised structure
  • Tailor decompositions for different audiences or decision-makers who focus on different aspects of the same issue
  • Compare how different driver structures lead to different indicator priorities and forecasting outcomes

The Primary Decomposition

Every analysis has exactly one primary decomposition. The primary decomposition is the default - it is the one that appears when you first navigate to an analysis's decomposition section.

In Manage Decompositions, open a decomposition's row menu and choose Set as Primary to make it the default. The current primary cannot be deleted; make another decomposition primary before removing it.

Creating a New Decomposition

Open the gear menu on your analysis's decomposition page and select Manage Decompositions. Select New Decomposition, enter a title, and submit. The new decomposition opens in the builder, where you can generate drivers and indicators or add them yourself.

Cloning a Decomposition

Open Manage Decompositions from the decomposition gear menu. Find the decomposition you want to copy, open its row's gear menu, and choose Clone. Open the copy from the list to edit it. The copy contains the drivers and indicators, with no forecasting-question links. Existing questions and their links remain with the original. Changes to the copy's drivers and indicators do not affect the original.

Cloning applies when you want to:

  • Branch off a working decomposition to test a different analytical structure without changing the original
  • Create a snapshot of your current decomposition before a major revision
  • Give a collaborator their own copy to modify independently

Switching Between Decompositions

When an analysis has more than one decomposition, a dropdown switcher appears in the decomposition navigation bar. Use it to move between decompositions without leaving the page. Each decomposition has its own builder view, visualizations, and export options.

Decompositions and the Hinsley Chat

When you use the Hinsley chat within an analysis, the chat is aware of which decomposition you are currently viewing. AI-generated suggestions for new drivers or indicators will target the active decomposition. You can also switch the chat's context to a different decomposition using the context selector in the chat header, so the AI's suggestions and reasoning always align with the decomposition you are working on.

Relationship to Scenario Sets

Multiple decompositions and scenario sets are complementary features. While scenario sets let you explore alternative framings of possible futures, multiple decompositions let you explore alternative ways of breaking down the analytical problem itself. The two can be combined - for example, pairing one decomposition with multiple scenario sets, or vice versa.